Skip to content

Free Standard Shipping on orders over $150

Free Standard Shipping on orders over $150

Language

English

Currency

Search

Fair Play Projects

Search

Holiday Shop
New
Shop By

SHOP ALL

CREATIVE SUPPLIES
coloring + painting sculpture + clay origami + paper craft craft tools + glue sketchbooks coloring books + blanks stamps washi tape stickers

CREATIVE KITS
jewelry kits art kits needlecraft kits dollhouse kits science kits origami kits

STATIONERY + DESKTOP
cards letter sets memo pads + notebooks desktop organization desktop tools pens + pencils erasers stamps stickers washi tape

TOYS
active + outdoor toys blocks + construction cars + trucks stuffed animals + dolls dollhouse + miniatures dress up + pretend play games + puzzles bath + water play keepsakes + trinkets fidgets wood toys baby toys

BOOKS
picture books activity books blank books bookmarks book bundles

PARTY FAVORS + SUPPLIES
party favors party decorations cards + tags sweets + treats

ACCESSORIES + BEAUTY
small accessories purses + bags bath + beauty tattoos

DECOR
room decor ornaments
Gift Guides
Let's Blog!

Search

Goes great with

Mini Pre-Inked Single Stamp

Several colorful and decorative bell charms laying in a line on a blue background

from $1⁵⁰ from $1.50

Mini Shopping Basket

$10⁰⁰ $10.00

Add order note Close

Subtotal

$0.00

Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.

Your cart is currently empty.

New
Let's Blog!

Unexpected Gifts (10+)

893 products

Creative Supplies
Creative Kits
Stationery & Desktop
Toys
Miniatures
Party Favors & Supplies
Accessories & Beauty
Books
Decor

Made in the USA
Made in Europe
Made in Japan
Handmade
Party Favors

893 products

Sure, all they asked for was a wad of cash, but even testy teens who swear they've seen it all like to see something new sometimes! Surprise them with one of these quirky trinkets that they didn't even know they wanted. They'll laugh, they'll roll their eyes, and they'll love it!

Mini Pre-Inked Single Stamp

Several colorful and decorative bell charms laying in a line on a blue background

from $1⁵⁰ from $1.50

Mini Shopping Basket

$10⁰⁰ $10.00

Mini Kewpie Doll

from $2⁵⁰ from $2.50

Single Puzzle Erasers

from $1⁵⁰ from $1.50

Colorful Patterns Hair Tie Bracelet Singles

Tiny set of colored pencils in a blue package sitting on a small yellow notebook against a light purple background.

Tiny Mini Colored Pencils

Fortune Teller Fish

Rainbow Twirler

from $6⁰⁰ from $6.00

Several colorful googly-eye coin purses with metal button on light pink background.

Googly Eye Coin Purse

$11⁵⁰ $11.50

Matchbox Village

Several brightly colored plastic balloon cars with brightly colored balloons attached to their tops.

Tiny Stickers in a Tiny Box

Bird Clip Ornament

Small Sunprint Kit

$10⁰⁰ $10.00

Several small colorful notebooks with orange background.

Googly Eye Leather Notebook

Mini Rainbow Clay

Matchbox Castle Blocks

Little Letter Set

Sweetheart Kewpie Doll

from $3⁵⁰ from $3.50

Playful Pre-Inked Stamp

Matchbox Mini Train

Matchbox Memo Note

$12⁰⁰ $12.00

Petit Bunny Lip Gloss Bar

Frog Flashlight

$12⁵⁰ $12.50

Passers Mate Mechanical Pencil

Six packaged Magic Butterflies in a variety of colors fanned out on a light blue background.

Magic Flying Butterfly

A group of colorful, small, vintage-style jelly baskets artfully scattered on a light blue background.

Mini Retro Jelly Basket

Kite paper and a kite paper instruction booklet laying on a wooden background

from $14⁰⁰ from $14.00

Thin Rainbow Hair Tie Bracelet Singles

Deco Beauty Nail Art Stickers

from $10⁰⁰ from $10.00

Six colorful monster shaped gel pens on a yellow background

Monster Gel Pen

Mustache Party Blower

Several brightly colored sketch pads laying flat

Graf it Sketch Pad

from $4⁵⁰ from $4.50

A pile of small pastel and metallic surprise balls on a light blue background with a hand reaching in to grab one.

Small Surprise Ball

Small Snowglobe

$19⁰⁰ $19.00

1 2 3 … 23 Next

Recently viewed

Follow Us

see you on Instagram

Visit the Store

meet me in saint paul

Gift Guides

lots of fun ideas

Get $5 off of your next order by subscribing to our newsletter!

Enter your email Subscribe

Get in touch

718-912-8757
Email us

Follow us

Instagram

SHOP

shop all
create
play
books + games
SEARCH

VISIT

1591 Selby Avenue
St. Paul, MN 55104
651-363-3507
HOURS
10:30-4:30 Tues-Sat
12-3 Sunday
Closed Mondays

SUPPORT

about & contact
shipping & delivery
returns
privacy
terms & conditions

© 2025 Fair Play Projects

Unexpected Gifts (10+)